Scotland
Stuart Hogg 6 The full-back did not have the chance to make too many counterattacks but gave a steady display and was a rock in defence.
Tommy Seymour 6 Always looked dangerous and made some telling breaks in the first half but worryingly had to be helped off after 64 minutes.
Huw Jones 7 Two tries against England last year and his early score here rocked England on their heels. His second brought the house down
Finn Russell masterminds historic Scotland victory over England
Pete Horne 6 He spurned a two-man overlap that could have given Scotland a second-half try but is forging an excellent partnership with Jones.
Sean Maitland 7 The Saracens wing took his try well with an outstanding finish and kept the dangerous Anthony Watson under wraps. Excellent.
Finn Russell 8 No player on the pitch was under more scrutiny and he responded brilliantly. Kicked well and turned England’s defence inside out.
Greig Laidlaw 7 Restored to the starting lineup against France and has now cemented his place. Replaced by Price in the final quarter.
Gordon Reid 7 The London Irish man held his own against Dan Cole and no one would know there was a Scottish front-row crisis.
Stuart McInally 7 The hooker made important tackles in his best display in a Scottish shirt. Was accurate in the lineout and strong in the scrum.
Simon Berghan 6 The New Zealand-born tighthead is Scotland’s heaviest forward and he made it count. Made some crunching tackles.
Grant Gilchrist 7 Scotland’s best ball-carrier against France was strong again although his discipline let him down. Everywhere in the first half.
John Barclay plays down Scotland’s tunnel scuffle with England
Jonny Gray 7 The lock put painful memories of Twickenham last year behind him and was Scotland’s most prolific tackler. Good lineout work.
John Barclay (capt) 7 He did some outstanding work at the breakdown and was particularly impressive in the first half. Good, abrasive display.
Hamish Watson 7 Built for speed and should have used that pace to score a try but Horne’s pass was wayward. Always a thorn in England’s side.
Ryan Wilson 7 Nasty incident when he appeared to run his fingernails down Hughes’s face, but Wilson refused to bow to the heftier No 8.
REPLACEMENTS
Jamie Bhatti (for Reid 55) 6; WP Nel (for Berghan 68) Made a big impact in the scrum 7; Tim Swinson (for Gilchrist 55) 6; David Denton (for Wilson 68) 6; Ali Price (for Laidlaw 62) Added some extra tempo in the last quarter 6; Nick Grigg (for Horne 72) 6; Blair Kinghorn (for Seymour 64) 6
England
Mike Brown 5 The full-back had been outstanding against Wales but was stuck doing defensive duties on a miserable night.
Anthony Watson 5 He and Brown were at fault for Jones’s second try. Almost wriggled though for a late try and made some big tackles.
Jonathan Joseph 6 The hammer of the Scots last year but not this time. He was mostly restricted to defensive duties and half-breaks.
Owen Farrell 6 England’s best player against Wales and his try hauled them back into the game; was unlucky to see a second turned down.
Jonny May 5 He had few chances to repeat his try-scoring feats against Wales. The wing made some decent runs but faded after the break.
George Ford 5 Had the odd experience of being eclipsed by his opposite number and playing behind a beaten pack before being replaced.
Danny Care 6 He had a decent night under pressure from the Scotland back row. Kicked well but unable to attack around the fringes.
Eddie Jones’ timid guests floored by Scotland’s brutal first-half flurry | Andy Bull
Mako Vunipola 5 Those scrummaging sessions against the Georgian pack paid off but he was not at his best in open play. Looked weary.
Dylan Hartley (capt) 5 England’s captain became his country’s second most-capped player. But question marks will be against his place in the side.
Dan Cole 6 He was his usual powerful self at scrums and made some important tackles but unable to impose himself on the game.
Joe Launchbury 7 Not the way to mark your 50th cap, but he had a decent game in the engine-room and was influential in the lineout.
Maro Itoje 6 Not at his best in this tournament by his standards. Had a solid game in the lineout and made some good carries.
Courtney Lawes 6 He tackled well and will be disappointed that his thumping hit on Barclay did not give Farrell his second try.
Chris Robshaw 6 Made his mark at the breakdown early on and forced to play at No 8 for much of the second half. Worked tirelessly, as always.
Nathan Hughes 6 Rushed back to fitness for his ball-carrying power. He was England’s best forward before his withdrawal after the break.
REPLACEMENTS
Jamie George (for Hartley 55) 6; Joe Marler (for Vunipola 68) 6; Harry Williams (for Cole 64) 6; George Kruis (for Launchbury 71) 6; Sam Underhill (for Hughes 53) Made an impact but also got yellow card 5; Richard Wigglesworth (for Care 71) 6; Ben Te’o (for Ford 64) 6; Jack Nowell (for Brown 55) 6.